Slice on Broadway Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Slice on Broadway, a culinary gem located at 108 E Main St, Carnegie, PA. Celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza, Slice on Broadway offers a mouthwatering menu designed to satisfy every craving. Choose from a variety of customizable pizzas with sizes ranging from a 12" Small to a 20" Ginormous pie. Each slice boasts a perfect blend of crispy crust and rich, flavorful sauce.
- Breadsticks and Garlic Knots: A delightful complement to your pizza, featuring options like Pesto Breadsticks and Cheesy Garlic Knots.
- Italian Subs: Customers rave about the life-changing Italian sub, known for its fresh ingredients and superb taste.
With friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, Slice on Broadway is more than just a meal; it’s a community experience. Whether dining in or taking out, each visit promises a slice of happiness.
Calzones
Italian Stallion Calzone
Salami, Mortadella, Capicola, Onions, Banana Peppers, House Blend Cheese, Ricotta, and Magic Garlic Seasoning
Grandma's Garden
Baby Spinach, Red Onion, Green & Red Peppers, Black Olives & Mushrooms, House Blend Cheese, Ricotta, and Magic Garlic Seasoning
Buff Chick Calzone
Buffalo Chicken, House Blend Cheese, and Magic Garlic Seasoning served with Ranch on the side
Pepperoni-Zonie
Pepperoni, House Blend Cheese, Ricotta, and Magic Garlic Seasoning
Signore Steak Pizzaiola
Sliced Steak, Green & Red Peppers, Onions, House Blend Cheese, Ricotta, and Magic Garlic Seasoning
Brocc-O
Broccolini & Hot Italian Sausage, House Blend Cheese, Ricotta, and Magic Garlic Seasoning
Chicken On The Parm Calzone
Sliced Breaded Chicken, House Blend Cheese, Ricotta, and Magic Garlic Seasoning
My Poor Meatball
Meatballs, House Blend Cheese, Ricotta, and Magic Garlic Seasoning
Create Your Own Calzone
House blend cheese, ricotta, and magic garlic seasoning with side of red sauce.
Chocolate Mousse Cheese Cake
Raspberry Swirl Cheese Cake
New York Plain Cheesecake
Tiramisu Cup
Espresso soaked cake topped with mascarpone cream and a dusting of cocoa, served in a cup.
Cannoli Cake
Everything you love about cannoli but in a cake.
Sweet Things
Extras
Quart Of Sauce
Side Of Sauce
Pint Of Ranch
Quart Of Ranch
Side Of Garlic Sauce
Pint Of Sauce
Side Of Ranch
20oz Starry
20oz Diet Pepsi
2L Diet Pepsi
Lemonata Pellegrino
2L Starry
2L Pepsi
20oz Water
Orange Pellegrino
20oz Pepsi
Drinks
House Pies
Spicy Italian Pizza
House Red Sauce, Hot Sopressata, Capicola, Pepperoni, and Banana Pepper Rings. This one is sure to give your taste buds an offer they can’t refuse.
Capricciosa
House Red Sauce, Prosciutto, Artichoke Hearts, Black Olives, and Mushrooms. It’s Italian for capricious. We don’t know what that means, so we just call it delicious.
Hawaiian Style
House Red Sauce, Pineapple, Capicola, and Sliced Red Onions. If you’re going to put Pineapple on Pizza, you may as well do it right.
Green Monster
Basil Pesto Sauce, Ricotta, Fresh Baby Spinach, Artichoke Hearts, and Roasted Red Peppers. It’s scary good!
Supremo
House Red Sauce, Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Green Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, and Sliced Red Onions. Kitchen sink not included.
Bianca Pizza
White Sauce, Fresh Chopped Garlic, Fresh Sliced Tomatoes topped with Ricotta Cheese
The Luca Pie
House Red Sauce, Pepperoni, Sausage, and Bacon. There’s no ‘sleeping with the fishes’ with this one!
Pizza Di Broccolini
U.S. Pizza Cup winning Pizza Rich Ricotta Cream Sauce topped with Hot Italian Sausage and Garlic Roasted Broccolini...Mangia!
Parm Raised Chicken Pizza
White Sauce with Breaded Chicken Breast, topped with our House Red Sauce and dollops of Ricotta Cheese.
John's BBQ Chicken
BBQ Sauce, Sliced Chicken, and Red Onions. A Tribute Pizza to a man passionate about family, friends and great BBQ.
Cheese Steak Pizza
Featured on the Travel Channel White Pizza topped with Sliced Steak, Green Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, Mushrooms, and Sliced Red Onions. The classic Hoagie you love is now a pizza.
Bazzy Pie
No Cheese, little extra sauce & Fresh Mozzarella
Santino Pizza
Thicker Crust with Pepperoni, Sausage, Meatball, and House Red Sauce, House Blend Cheese and Ricotta.
Rico's Favorite
White Sauce AND Red Sauce with House Blend Cheese, topped with Pepperoni and Fresh Roasted Banana Peppers.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
White Pizza topped with Sliced Chicken and a healthy dose of Buffalo Wing Sauce. It’s all the joy of Buffalo Wings, without all those pesky bones.
Ms Bazzy Pie
Thicker Crust, No Cheese, Little Extra Sauce
Slaughterhouse Five
House Red Sauce, Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Capicola, and Prosciutto. Vegetarians need not apply.
Goomba Pizza
Ricotta Cream Sauce topped with Mushrooms, Bacon and Spinach.
Guido Pizza
Hot Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers & Red Onions.
Margherita
House Red Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella (Or Di Latte), Fresh Basil, and Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Pleasing palates since 1889!
Stuffed Banana Pepper Pizza
Just like the classic Stuffed Banana Peppers, but on a pie. Fresh Roasted Banana Peppers, Meatballs, and Sauce covered with Cheese on Thicker Crust.
Fancy Pants
Basil Pesto Sauce, Thinly Sliced Prosciutto, Baby Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers, and Ricotta. Best enjoyed whilst wearing a top hat and monocle, old chap!
Athena
White Pizza Topped with Fresh Baby Spinach, Fresh Tomatoes, and Crumbled Feta Cheese. Our tribute to The Goddess of Good Pizza.
Garden Pizza
House Red Sauce, Fresh Baby Spinach, Mushrooms, Artichoke Hearts, Black Olives, Green Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, and Sliced Red Onions. PETA would be proud.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Dance
Our White Sauce base topped with Sliced Chicken, crispy Bacon and drizzled with our House Made Ranch Dressing
Dayak Gonzo
White Pizza topped with Fresh Spinach, Sliced Steak, Red Onions, Crispy Bacon, and Gorgonzola Cheese. This one is pretty as a picture... a really good picture.
Paisano Pizza
Thicker Crust Ricotta Cream Sauce, Meatballs, & Basil topped with a drizzle of Red Sauce.
Large Buffalo & Cheese Breadstick
Large Breadstick
Small Pesto Breadstick
Large Pesto Breadstick
Small Breadstick
Small Cheese Breadstick
Large Cheese Bredstick
Small Buffalo & Cheese Breadstick
Bread Sticks
Rolls
Pepperoni Roll
Pepperoni, cheese and our magic garlic seasoning rolled together and served with side of sauce
Steak & Onion Roll
Steak, onion, cheese and our magic garlic seasoning rolled together and served with side of sauce
Spinach Roll
Spinach, cheese and our magic garlic seasoning rolled together and served with side of sauce
Baked Penne
Penne Pasta topped with our House Red Sauce and Cheese.
Chicken Parm Dinner
Breaded and Seasoned Chicken Breast topped with our House Red Sauce and Cheese served with a side of Penne.
Meatball Parm Dinner
Three of our almost famous Meatballs over Penne Pasta all topped with our House Red Sauce and Cheese.
Pasta Di Broccolini Dinner
Chicken and Broccolini over Penne Pasta tossed with our House Garlic and Oil and topped with Cheese.
Dinners
Garlic Knots
Cheesy Garlic Knots
House blend cheese topped on pillows of dough tossed in our garlic sauce.
3 Garlic Knots
8 pillows of dough tossed with fresh garlic, olive oil, and spices, served with a side of our house pizza sauce.
8 Garlic Knots
8 pillows of dough tossed with fresh garlic, olive oil, and spices, served with a side of our house pizza sauce.
Garlic Knot Parmesan
Pillows of dough tossed in our garlic sauce topped with our house red sauce and cheese blend.
Buffalo Chicken Hoagie
Sliced Chicken tossed in Spicy Buffalo Sauce, topped with Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Sliced Red Onion. No Buffalo were harmed in the making of this sandwich.
Greenhouse Hoagie
Mushrooms, Spinach, Black Olives, Green and Red Peppers, House Blend Cheese, and Artichoke Hearts topped with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion and House Balsamic Dressing.
Venetian
Hot Sopressata, Genoa Salami, House Blend Cheese, topped with Artichoke Hearts, Fresh Baby Spinach, Sliced Red Onions, and our House Balsamic Vinaigrette. Gondoliers love it!
Chicken Club
Sliced Chicken, House Blend Cheese, topped with Crispy Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and our Basil Pesto Sauce. Hungry? Join the Club!
Ultra Mega Chicken
Sliced Chicken, Crispy Bacon, House Blend Cheese, topped with Banana Pepper Rings, Sliced Red Onions, and our Spicy Ranch Dressing. The legend has become reality.
Luca Hoagie
Thinly Sliced Prosciutto, Hot Sopressata, House Blend Cheese, topped with Roasted Red Peppers and our House Balsamic Vinaigrette (or try it with our Pesto Sauce). The first sandwich we ever made, and still one of our favorites!
Steak Caballero
Sliced Steak, House Blend Cheese, topped with Jalapeno Peppers, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, and our Spicy Ranch Dressing. Muy picante! Muy bueno!
Spicy Italian Hoagie
Hot Sopressata, Capicola, Pepperoni, House Blend Cheese, topped with Banana Pepper Rings and our House Balsamic Vinaigrette. Mamma Mia, that’s a spicy sangweech!
Italian Hoagie
Genoa Salami, Capicola, Mortadella, House Blend Cheese, topped with Lettuce, Tomato, Sliced Red Onions, and our House Balsamic Vinaigrette. A classic!
Gonzo Hoagie
Sliced Steak, Crispy Bacon, Crumbled Gorgonzola, House Blend Cheese, topped with Baby Spinach, Sliced Red Onions, and our House Balsamic Vinaigrette. You’ll go Gonzo when you taste it! (No, it’s not named after the Muppet.)
Chicken Parm Hoagie
Breaded Chicken Breast covered in House Red Sauce and Cheese. Our sauciest creation yet!
Meatball Hoagie
Meatballs, Sauce, and Cheese Feeling spicy? Add Fresh Banana Peppers.
Steak Hoagie
Sliced Steak, House Blend Cheese, topped with Lettuce, Tomato, Sliced Red Onions, and our House Balsamic Vinaigrette (or Mayo, if you prefer). It’s just good!
Hoagies
Create Your Own PIzza
16" Large
20" Ginormous
20" pie, serves 16 slices.
12" Small
12" pie, serves 8 slices.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Sliced Chicken tossed in Spicy Buffalo Sauce, Fresh Tomatoes, Sliced Red Onions, Green Peppers, Garlic Croutons, Mozzarella, and Provolone, served atop chopped Green Leaf Lettuce and Fresh Baby Spinach, with your choice of Dressing.
Classic Chicken Salad
Sliced Chicken, Fresh Tomatoes, Sliced Red Onions, Green Peppers, Garlic Croutons, Mozzarella, and Provolone, served atop chopped Green Leaf Lettuce and Fresh Baby Spinach, with your choice of Dressing. Healthy enough for a hen; hearty enough for a rooster.
Antipasto Salad
Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Artichoke Hearts, Sliced Tomatoes, Onions, Roasted Red Peppers, Banana Pepper Rings, Black Olives, Crumbled Feta Cheese, and Croutons, served atop chopped Green Leaf Lettuce and Fresh Baby Spinach, with your choice of Dressing. It’s not really anti-anything, except maybe hunger.
The Big Guy Salad
Fresh Tomatoes, Fresh Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, Banana Pepper Rings, Black Olives, Sliced Red Onions, Garlic Croutons, Mozzarella, and Provolone, served atop chopped Green Leaf Lettuce and Baby Spinach, with your choice of Dressing. It’s a salad, only bigger, with lots of stuff in it.
The Little Guy
Chopped Green Leaf Lettuce and Fresh Baby Spinach, topped with Tomatoes, Sliced Red Onions, and Garlic Croutons, Cheese, plus your choice of Dressing. It doesn’t mind playing second fiddle.
Bacon, Spinach & Gorgonzola Salad
Chopped Bacon, Crumbled Gorgonzola Cheese, Fresh Tomatoes, Sliced Red Onions, and Garlic Croutons, served atop mounds of Fresh Baby Spinach, with your choice of Dressing. Who knew Bacon could be so sophisticated?
Nearly Pittsburgh Steak Salad
Sliced Steak, Fresh Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Fresh Tomatoes, Sliced Red Onions, Garlic Croutons, Mozzarella, and Provolone, served atop Chopped Green Leaf Lettuce and Fresh Baby Spinach, with your choice of Dressing. So good, you won’t even miss the Fries!